Podcast episode dives into historical Kingston murder
Posted Feb 16, 2026 08:15:03 AM.
Last Updated Feb 17, 2026 01:37:03 PM.
It looked like a single vehicle crash at first, but it quickly turned into something more sinister—a homicide.
On February 14, 1992, William Neil left his auto shop in Westbrook, Ont., just outside Kingston, after receiving a phone call from an unknown person that made him visibly upset, police said. He was found shot to death in his vehicle on Cutler Road.
His killer has eluded investigators for decades.
The 56-year-old’s sister-in-law, Nancy Neil, says he deserves justice.
“I think we all do. I know his sisters and his brother definitely would have liked an answer before they passed away, but they didn’t get it,” said Neil.
Testimonies from friends and family at the time explained that Billy was well-liked. Officials said they were able to trace some of his movements, but there are gaps in their information.
Detective Staff Sergeant Erin Thomas with the OPP’s Criminal Investigation Branch says over the years this case has been reviewed and reinvestigated.
“Each thread of evidence that we have and that we’ve gathered has been re-examined sometimes more than once. Possible suspects have been re-evaluated at every stage and we still believe this case is solvable,” said Thomas.
This is one of the cases that will be featured on the new season of “Tracking a Killer: The Cold Case Files” podcast.
Episode 3 is now available on the Frequency Podcast Network or wherever you get your podcasts.
